A study of personal identity development in a family

Excerpts from the film Once were warriors, 1994

General ideas about the development of identity: An example from a film study of how different personal identities emerged in the one family

This film study of identity is useful in that it explores how five individuals in a family sort personal identity each going in different directions.

The French sociologist Bourdieu wrote about ‘life structure' as a way of looking at people's lived-out identity. Observation of behaviour gives insight into people's self understanding – there is congruence between the two. This principle is useful in the interpretation of film narratives. Characters' identities are inferred from their behaviour and dialogue.

Other identity principles are prominent in the film looked at below:-

  • Individuals draw on various cultural elements (external identity resources) to shape and sustain their sense of identity.
  • Other identity resources are more internal and personal (values and commitments).
  • Healthy identity is firmly grounded in personal, internal resources.
  • Identity problems can occur when individuals are too dependent on external identity resources. This is particularly the case where the identity resources to which the individual turns are physically and psychologically damaging both to themselves and others.

The New Zealand film Once Were Warriors (1994) has a level of graphic violence that would be grounds for caution about showing it at school – even though the novel has been studied in some senior classes. However, for adults, the harrowing story of the urban Maori family of Jake and Beth is a useful one for film study of identity issues. The approach to interpretation illustrated here can be applied to other films. In this film, identity can be used as a lens for exploring the thinking and behaviour of the main characters. From this perspective, Beth and Jake, and their three eldest children Nig, Grace and Boogie, are all searching for personal identity in different ways, drawing on different resources as they do so.

Film clips from Once were warriors illustrating the different trajectories and reference points in the family members' quest for a sense of personal identity

IMPORTANT NOTE: Before you look at the six video clips, read the short biographical information that you need to know for each before you look at the particular clips -- watch after reading each description below.
Look at six short video clips on how the film Once were warriors shows examples of how different members of the family seek to develop some sense of identity by referencing to different ideas (cultural meanings) Note the final key point in video 6 – Boogie says you “wear your patch (tattoo) on the inside” – the suggestion that it is internal identity resources that are so important.

Identity 1. Jake the Mus

Jake the ‘Mus': For Jake his self-understanding and self-expression seemed embedded mainly in interactions with his drinking mates. He liked to see himself reflected in the fear that other men showed when confronted by his aggression and awesome capacity to fight, and as the affable centre of attention when he hosted his hotel friends to after hours parties and sing-alongs in his home. The fearsome temper that was aroused when his macho image was questioned by his wife, Beth, suggested that no matter how much he might protest the opposite, he was not really happy or secure in the way he had become defined as ‘Jake the Mus'. When drunk and antagonised, he brutalised his wife, but he seemed to avoid any acknowledgment that ‘wife beater' was a component of his identity – this he could choose to ignore when he thought of himself as a genuine family man.

Identity 2: Beth (Mother)

Beth: Beth appeared to love Jake and was happy when things were going well. But her experience of his brutality and his apparently greater commitment to his drinking mates than to his own children made her wonder whether she needed to break away from him and seek support elsewhere – perhaps within a traditional Maori community.

Identity 3: Nig (eldest son)

Nig: Jake's oldest son, Nig, found the social situation of the home revolting – particularly his father's behaviour. He left to seek some self-definition away from the family. But he found it hard to break away from the image of being ‘the son of Jake the Mus'. He did find an alternative identity of a type, but it was with a tough fringe group called the Brown Fists, with their studded leather vests and highly tattooed bodies and faces; its identity was heavily invested in distinctive clothing, personal appearance and ritualised behaviour. His initiation ceremony involved a beating at the hands of the group and getting a ‘patch' – a tattoo across his face. Jake is of course unimpressed with the tattoo.

Identity 4: Boogie (younger son)

Boogie: Jake's younger son, Mark (known as Boogie), was removed from the family into the custody of welfare – fallout from his seeking identity with youth involved in petty crime, stealing car radios. The failure of his badly beaten up mother to make a court appearance was the factor that influenced the juvenile court decision that nothing could be done to rehabilitate Boogie if he remained in the family home. Despite periodic fractious behaviour, Boogie learned something valuable from the supervisor of the remand home, who became a mentor for his troublesome young brood. He showed them that the future of the deprived ‘once were warriors' Maoris lay in cultivating an internal warriorship of the spirit. He encouraged the boys to ritualise their interior strength and courage in fearsome hakas – war dances as impressive as any by the legendary All Blacks. But he insisted that their energy had to be channelled into ‘inner resources', otherwise it would be wasted and misused in the spiralling violence that was already devastating the Maori community.

identity 5: Grace (daughter)

Grace: Jake's 13-year-old daughter, Grace, came across as perhaps the most attractive personality in the family. She was gentle and friendly. She was traumatised by the brutality in the family but seemed to remain optimistic about life.

Identity 6: "Wearing a patch on the inside"
When Nig suggested to him that he too should have his face tattooed, Mark replied with self-assurance in words which were like an icon for identity and the key principle, or climax statement, in the film: ‘I wear mine on the inside'. Inner strength was the belief or mantra that could give direction and meaning to his life and some sense of healthy personal identity.

The rest of the story

This philosophy of 'warriorship of the spirit', drawing on the Maori heritage, gave Boogie some sense of worthwhile identity and something to believe in. It helped him interpret the frustration in which his own family was tragically caught. It helped him cope with trauma when Grace committed suicide. She had been sexually abused by her uncle, one of Jake's regular drinking mates, during the all-night parties. Overwhelmed, she hanged herself from the tree behind the house before her mother returned from an unsuccessful search to find her.

Heartbroken, Beth regretted not following earlier her intuition to leave Jake and take the family (including Poly, Abe and the baby Huata) to a Maori traditional community in the country where she felt there were the spiritual resources that would give them more dignity and purpose in life. Later, both Beth and Jake discovered the abuse of Grace, with inevitable recriminations.

Beth then left Jake and with the remainder of the family set off for the Maori community. Jake remained unchanged in his established identity as ‘the Mus'. Mark identified with the emerging spiritual strength in his mother.

When Nig suggested to him that he too should have his face tattooed, Mark replied with self-assurance in words which were like an icon for identity and the key principle, or climax statement, in the film: ‘I wear mine on the inside'. Inner strength was the belief or mantra that could give direction and meaning to his life and some sense of healthy personal identity.

The film portrayed the struggle of individuals for a satisfying self-understanding, self-expression and sense of self-worth in a subculture of brutality and oppression. The character Mark articulated one of the messages coming through the film: confronting moral degradation needs inner strength and values; like spiritual principles, they help with interpretation of the problem as well as providing the courage and motivation needed to take action to change the situation.

Click here to return to the main identity study home page